Wednesday, June 1, 2016
Wait, Moses Was A Founding Father?
These changes have been proposed before, and there is a reason that the folks behind them take this approach to spreading their ideas: as one advocate stated in her book One Nation Under God, “This battle for our nation’s children and who will control their education and training is crucial to our success for reclaiming our nation.” The bromide “our children are our future” is cliché but true, shaping that future through the values we teach them is a highly effective way of inserting our own agendas into that future. The faction of politically and religiously conservative, mostly “evangelical”, activists who take this approach to education have often done so with little attention paid them outside the arenas in which they operate, but the implications for the future of civic and religious understanding in this country could be enormous.
The event that brought this strategy to the forefront of my attention occurred in 2010, when the Texas Board of Education (TBOE, or the School Board) attempted to pass curriculum standards which made religion and history scholars, and Texas teachers alike, cringe at the level of disingenuousness with which they handled the founding of the United States. In their attempts to insert the notion that the US was founded by Christians as a Christian nation, they played fast and loose with both the historical understanding of who the Founders were, and with the clear trend of both the Constitution and the body of juris prudence since then establishing that the US government is and should be religiously neutral.
Examples of standards the TBOE attempted to pass include attempts to treat the Bible as inerrant and historically and scientifically factual, decontextualizing quotes from the Founding Fathers in support of the notion that America is a “Christian nation” , and inserting the Ten Commandments, Moses, and “Judeo-Christian law” as influences both on the Founders and the Constitution. The idea, says Chancey, is to “Christianize the American past” thereby “Christianiz[ing] the American future.” Justine Ellis confirms the goal of this approach: by linking Christian values with a Jewish and “Judeo-Christian” continuity, conservative Evangelical textbook consultants could make the case that American colonists were influenced by and a part of the same continuity, making the United States itself a product of this “linear trajectory” and, ultimately, of the will of God.
The underlying question I had when investigating the Texas textbook kerfuffle was “who gets to rewrite history?” We like to think of education being an objective presentation of facts, whether scientific, mathematical, or historical. And while there is some flexibility of interpretation allowed in the arts, we assume history is cut and dried—so the idea that Social Studies classes could be shaped to support an agenda may be a foreign concept. As I’ve pointed out, however, this is exactly what might have happened had the TBOE gotten its way, and still points to the question of who it is that actually supports that agenda.
Interestingly—or perhaps predictably—most of the advocates for the more questionable curriculum standadrds were not teachers or scholars or historians, but “concerned citizens” like David Barton, Don McLeroy, and Cynthia Dunbar. Their concern is that Christianity is being left out of the classroom, anathema since in their minds “America is a Christian nation”. But Barton’s degree is in Religious Studies, McLeroy is a dentist, and Dunbar is a lawyer who supports teaching creationism in science classes. These are not experts, and it seems terribly problematic to leave curricula in their hands. As Tom Barber, a publishing executive put it, “board members don’t know anything at all about content.”
Perhaps more interestingly, at no point in my research of this topic did any of the curriculum change advocates support their positions with any Biblical authority. They push for that authority to have a place in the classroom, they want Moses to be on the list of Thomas Jefferson’s influences along with Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, but do not support their positions with Biblical texts. The use of the Bible is the use of an idea rather than a textual support. I came across vague notions of America as the new Israel or America as the promised land, but nowhere have I seen any reference to the Bible itself as an authority on this issue. Even the “city on a hill” quote is taken from the Winthrop sermon rather than the original source. These folks want “Biblical values” but cannot delineate what these are, or why they want them other than by a circular appeal to those values’ own authority.
But so what? Why does any of this matter? I have learned over the course of my entire education to think for myself; to question everything. When “Christian values” come up in the conversation, my ears perk up, and for good reason: I don’t want my religion, my God, my Bible used in oppressive, abusive, underhanded ways, particularly when it comes to educating children. I cannot support the use of Christianity to further a political agenda whose goal is to help those in power retain their own privilege and position.
No single blog post could contain the scope of the possible impact of this agenda; this, hopefully, was an introduction to one strategy. If you are interested in learning more, I am always available for conversation. Read my sources for yourself; ask me for more. Continue to think critically about what you hear in the news, even if it appeals to you at the surface level. Ask yourself: who is behind this (policy, activity, law, etc.)? Whom does it benefit? Whom does it hurt? Whom does it attempt to control? Why should this matter to me?
If you don’t ask the question, there is no way to find out the answer.
Sources:
Rob Boston, "Texas Tall Tale: Religious Right Cowboy David Barton's Fixin' to Rewrite the Social Studies Textbooks in the Lone Star State (and Maybe Yours Too)," Church & State 62, no. 7 (2009).
Cynthia Dunbar, qtd in Russell Shorto, "How Christian Were the Founders?," New York Times 14 (2010).
Mark A. Chancey, "A Textbook Example of the Christian Right: The National Council on Bible Curriculum in Public Schools," Journal of the American Academy of Religion 75, no. 3 (2007).
"Rewriting History for a Christian America: Religion and the Texas Social Studies Controversy of 2009-2010," The Journal of Religion 94, no. 3 (2014).
Justine Esta Ellis, "Constructing a Protestant Nation: Religion, Politics, and the Texas Public School Curriculum," Postscripts 7, no. 1 (2011).
Shorto, "How Christian Were the Founders?." New York Times Feb. 14, 2010
Sunday, August 31, 2014
Doing a New Thing
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Just a thought
Science is not a thing that is "to be accepted on faith". That's not the point of science. Science is the "systematic knowledge of the physical or material world gained through observation and experimentation" (Random House Webster's College Dictionary, 2001). Faith--at least what I understand faith to be--doesn't really have a place at the scientific table. Maybe the confusion comes when we, as believers, must reconcile that which we perceive with our own senses with what we believe in our hearts to be true. I get where that can cause some cognitive dissonance. I get that it might feel like a betrayal of the things we believe, that it might feel like everything we hold dear keeps getting smaller, or less relevant. But I just can't get behind the reaction that causes people to turn off their brains. God gave us our brains, and I just can't believe that, given that, we're meant not to use them.
(I also believe that faith and reason are not mutually exclusive. I know there are some things about God that are mysteries and always will be, but I hope to understand, with my brain, all the stuff I believe that can be dealt with by a rational mind.)
Questioning is as much a part of faith as it is a part of science, and the result is that when we question, we get closer to the truth. When we question our faith, the conclusions we reach are so much stronger for the questioning. When we question established scientific law, we end up with the copernican system and string theory and yes, Darwinian evolution. And it. Is. Beautiful.
And please don't tell me that science is "just a progression of people being wrong". That's sort of the point. Our whole **** civilization has basically operated on the same principle. When we question the world around us, we learn. And if we never find the absolute truth about it, that's okay. At least we never stopped learning.
In my world, the places where faith and science meet are so, so beautiful, and the God I believe in gets bigger every time I make a new connection, or read about a new discovery. I love the universe we live in, the universe God created, and every single thing I learn about it only enhances the vision I have of God as Creator.
Peace.
Thursday, March 17, 2011
Just so's everyone is on the same page...
So after laying some ground rules and deciding that a trip to San Diego was still in order (I have a lot of stuff here still, I'm guest preaching at my church on April 10th, and I have an important appointment to go to the next week), it was decided that I would come back to Jacksonville for all the same reasons I named when I moved the first time.
I feel good about this decision. And, though I'm bummed that I won't get to spend more time with lots of good people whom I love, this is important. And I'm glad I'm not turning my back on that.
Tuesday, March 8, 2011
Blue Like Jazz
So now my new dilemma is this: Glenn Beck, Sean Hannity, and Bill O'Reilly are all beloved children of God, and I am not allowed to hate them. I think I just found my practice for this Lent.
Saturday, January 15, 2011
Psychoanalysis
We're all trying to get along with each other; to be patient and flexible and make allowances. But we're not the same people we were seven years ago, and it's unreasonable to expect ourselves to have the same dynamic now that we did then.
It hasn't been easy. Besides all this loaded "I'mlivingwithmyparentsagain" angst, I miss my friends, my jobs, my community, and San Diego itself. But one thing, more than anything else--more than the cancer, more than my racist bosses--can trigger the worst feelings I've had since I've been back: My mom has this habit of gathering all the random things that I've left out--mail, a purse, shoes, whatever--and putting it in a pile near the door.
It makes me feel SO unwanted.
Monday, November 8, 2010
Random, but not silly at all...
Then, five days later, my dad was diagnosed with glioblastoma in his brain. I'll let you Wikipedia that if you want to be depressed. Otherwise, don't. Suffice it to say that it's a scary, uncool, depressing diagnosis.
On September 12th, I had no idea what pain was.
UPDATE:
My dad has been in chemo and radiation treatments for four weeks, and has just begun a clinical trial for an experimental cancer treatment drug, Avastin. He's doing really well with the treatments: he's eating well and getting plenty of rest, and he's able to get out and do things when he wants. He gets cold and tired more easily than he used to, and his head itches from the radiation, but on the other hand, he can tell people that he had brain surgery whenever he forgets something or does something weird. Which is handy, because that happened all the time before he had surgery, anyway.
Tuesday, September 14, 2010
Not dealing
This has been the suckiest summer ever.
I CANNOT deal with losing my daddy.
Tuesday, August 17, 2010
Toby
So I wake up at like 6:30 or so from an epic nap after work, because I'd only slept for like three hours the night before, and I'm still on the cranky side of Lea. I still have to get a shower, get dressed, and eat something, though, and the concert starts at 7.
I do all of the above, and then realize five minutes down the road that I've left my ticket pinned to my cork board. Turn around, retrieve ticket.
125 South was a quiet and delightful drive, until I had to fork over $4.50 for the toll. Why? Why does it need to cost me $5 to drive on this road? Oh right, because the entire state of California is not only about to break off into the Pacific, we're going to revert to the barter system while it happens because we're broke.
Get to the amphitheatre while telling Shannon that it's, like, 6 miles from the international border or something, and why the heck is there an Air Force C-130 parked by the infinitesimal hangar at Brown Field? Who knew.
Anyway, arrive thankful that I'm an hour late for the show, because there's very little traffic trying to park in the general parking lot. On the other hand, it means that the tailgaters now have something like a five hour head start on getting stupid before I show up looking for a space.
I turn into the back row of the dirt lot, and immediately regret not doing a three point turn right back into the row I came out of, because there are like 30 people in the aisle, partying it up. So, okay, now all of our objectives are exactly the same: get the obnoxious pickup truck with the sober chick driver out of the way of the party. I just want to park, and they want to continue being dumb. Our goals are one and the same, people! Can't we all just get along?
Nope.
So this couple are like, joined at the hip, and preparing for a huge makeout session right in the middle of the lot. Dude looks up at me knowingly, and then goes in for the kill. RIGHT IN FRONT OF MY FRONT BUMPER. So of course, I honk my horn. But I don't politely honk my horn, as if to say, "I know I'm inconveniencing you, and I'm so, so sorry, but could you pretty please move out of the way?" No, I push on my steering wheel with a constant pressure, and do not stop pushing until they flip me off and clear out of the aisle where I am supposed to be able to drive.
Okay, cool.
Nope.
Some other dude, because I have clearly wronged his friends, decides to exact his revenge by standing in front of my truck. So I tell him to move. He tells me to honk my horn. I tell him to move. He levels his oh-so-intimidating gaze at me through my windshield. I inch forward, and tell him to move. He backs up a little, I guess because he's not wasted enough to think that a trip to the hospital would be hilarious.
Then I look out my window, and another dude, in solidarity with making-out-couple and standing-in-front-of-my-truck-guy, decides to moon me.
SERIOUSLY? WE ALL WANT THE SAME THING! I want to get out of your way so I can park my truck, and you all want me to get out of the way so you can continue your drinking unimpeded by obnoxious sober people like me. What the hell?!? Just get out of the freaking road!
So finally, some girl with some sense, seeing as how I'm still slowly rolling forward into this guy, pulls the idiot in front of my truck out of the way, and I (with a final admiring glance at mooning guy's--well--moon) pull away and find a spot.
Grab my lovely blue straw Puerto Vallarta cowgirl hat, my purse, and my ticket, and proceed to the amphitheatre lawn in search of James and Tracy and Dave, who finally find me; set my purse under the lawn chair so that it's not completely obvious prey, enjoy Trace Adkins and Toby.
Halfway through Toby's set, this guy who had been standing not too far from us sidles up next to me, which freaks me out momentarily as he is quite large, and the boys have all gone to get drinks. He tells me that I should check my things, because the girl curled up next to us, whom I had thought to be asleep, has just been rifling through my purse and has thrown it back under the lawn chair. So much for my surveillance. I had been periodically making sure it was still there... : /
I thank him, and check my purse. My wallet, camera, and iPod are all missing. So I crouch down next to sleeping-bag-girl and tell her that my purse is strangely empty, and could I please have my things back?
To which she answers, while trying to hide the things she took under the rest of the stuff in her bag, "I don't have anything, I didn't take anything."
To which I say, "I just saw my wallet in there."
So naturally I check her bag, and immediately fish out my wallet. I show it to her and say, "So you see this wallet, this one with my ID in it? Turns out it's mine. Can I check your bag?"
"I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I didn't take anything, I don't have anything, you can look."
So I find my camera and my music and I step back over to our blankets, put my purse under a blanket in the chair, and tell James, who is furious. This is the best part, because furious James trips me out.
He goes and talks to her, and all she can say is still, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I didn't take anything."
Okay, chicky, okay. It teleported itself, I forget it has magical powers sometimes.
Seriously, people? Seriously?
I leave with no further trauma.
But... Seriously?
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
One year later...
I kept a bare-bones journal during the hike, meaning to eventually post it here. And so, in its not-so-entirety, it is.
8/12/2009
I'm sitting in a teeny little campsite somewhere near Baxter Creek on the JMT in Kings Canyon... The scenery is stunning, though it's freezing up here (somewhere shy of 10,000'). Molly is making breakfast, and I have a little time, so I thought I'd write about my first two hiking days.
Day 1
Taboose Pass to the JMT junction. The trailhead was somewhere in the neighborhood of 5K', and the pass was at 11,360'... 6K of elevation gain in 8 miles. I was dying. Hiking that trail ranks somewhere in the top 5 hardest things I've ever done. It was beautiful--the trail tracked a creek up into the mountains--and the eastern faces of these Sierra peaks are ruggedly stunning. By the end of the first hour, though, I was already wondering what I had gotten myself into. I started in scrub desert at 6:30 AM, and didn't make it to the top until late in the afternoon--sometime between 6 and 7. Twelve hours to walk 8 miles. Geez.
Matt found me when I was near the top, and generously traded his very light pack for mine so that we could make it down to meet Molly before dark.
It was so good to see them both... We ate and chatted for a while, and hiked another .5mi or mile to a camp site near some unnamed lake.
I didn't sleep well, and woke up wanting at least a couple more hours of Zs... But we had to eat and pack, and get on the trail. It was a beautiful way to wake up, though.
Day 2
Just shy of Lake Marjorie to Baxter Creek... We crossed Pinchot Pass pretty early in the day, and it was excruciating, but getting to the top, with the glorious view, was reward in itself. Then it was back downhill, to the tune of 4,000' over a few miles. So my uphill muscles got all used up on the first day, and my downhill muscles on the second--
We camped uphill from Baxter Creek this night; we sat around the campfire for a while and slept under the stars.
Oh! And we crossed this crazy suspension bridge in the afternoon. It was a highlight.
Day 3
Above Baxter Creek to Lake Charlotte. Matt and Molly have been stellar. I know I'm only slowing them down, but they have not stopped encouraging and helping me to adjust. They pretty much rock, and I'm so glad they invited me along.
Today we passed some beautiful lakes. As I write this, we are perched above Rae Lakes, taking a nap/swim/shower/laundry break before we tackle Glenn Pass, which is no joke. Matt is sleeping, Molly just finished painting a postcard of the view, and I wrote some poetry.
8/13/2009
I'm sitting on a rock in the sun, surrounded by loveliness on every side, in the middle of a mid-morning break. I split up with Matt and Molly a little while ago, but I'll get to that. First,
Day 3, cont'd
We left Rae Lakes after a few hours; Matt and I took a dip, Molly grabbed a shower, and we all did a little laundry.
It was so pretty there.
We had to make it up and over Glenn Pass that afternoon, though, so I led the slow trudge up to 12K'. I know my snail's pace was killing M & M, but they had nothing but encouraging words. Yup, they rock.
The pass was incredible--this narrow spine of rock, with not-quite-sheer, but intimidating, drops on either side. It truly felt as though we were sitting on top of the world.
I ate my first Slim Jim in years up there, much to Matt's delight.
We climbed down from the pass, and, since there was no water closer, had to hike all the way down to Charlotte Lake. This turned out to be the best "bad thing" ever: Not only did we catch a cutoff down to the lake (on a ranger's good advice), we also ran into our resupply guy quite fortuitously in the evening, meaning that we did our food exchange early, plus got to hang out with Doug and his friend Mike for the night.
And, miraculously, there was a group camped nearby that had packed their supplies--to include a kitchen and a cook--in on mules, and we got to finish off the leftovers of their amazing beef stew, biscuits, and salad. It was fabulous. Last night was also one of the peak nights of the Perseid meteor shower, and it was a beautiful night for stargazing. We lay there for a while, "oohing" and "ahhing" at the shooting stars before eventually falling asleep.
And, wondrously, it wasn't too cold.
Day 4
This morning, we woke up, had breakfast, gave some of the resupply back to Doug to pack out, and headed out. I wasn't sure if my hip was going to make it--today is a 16mi day for Matt and Molly, and tomorrow, too. There was talk of taking an extra day to finish the hike, but I know Matt didn't want to do that. So I walked with them to the junction of the JMT and the Lake Charlotte trail, but I knew I was only going to slow them down--plus, I didn't want to be in pain for the rest of the trip, either.
So I decided to hike out at Kearsarge Pass, and hopefully I'll be back at my truck--or at least to Independence--by tonight.
Epilogue
I made it up and over Kearsarge in decent time, even though, in addition to a painful muscle strain, my knee also started to ache badly on the downhill side. Two ladies on a day hike up to the pass and back kindly gave me a ride to my truck at the end of the day, and I drove back to San Diego that night.
I have to say, I was pretty proud of myself, even though I didn't finish. Matt and Molly couldn't have been better trail companions, and I'll always be grateful that I was able to tag along, and my first big hike will always be a standout memory.
Blue
It won't last.
Saturday, June 19, 2010
What are those stages, again?
I can't begin to describe the loss to my family. My grandma was one of the best and kindest people I have ever known, and I owe her a debt I can never hope to repay.
I hope I can be half the woman she was, and I hope I can make her proud.
Love you, Grandma.
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Baccalaureation
Monday, May 24, 2010
I know, shut up.
I think that Michael Emerson--the guy who played Ben Linus on Lost--is adorable. Wednesday, February 24, 2010
Reaction Paper #1
I really love physics, and am continually amazed when pure science collides with other, seemingly unrelated interests of mine. On Saturday, a series of photographs titled “Sunburn” captured my imagination by their fusion of beautiful photography with scientific thought.
The process is deceptively simple: The artist loads a homemade, large format camera with photo paper and takes an extended exposure picture. Over the course of several hours, the sun not only transforms the negative into a positive, but literally burns a hole or a path into the paper.
I was mesmerized by this method of allowing the process of photography to be performed by the sun itself. It spoke to my analytical mind and my “wanna-be” scientific imagination. I already admired photography for its ability to capture a sense of time, from single moments to several hours, on the page; it had never occurred to me before this that the process of taking a picture—of exposing film to light—could be pushed to achieve this effect.
The three pieces, particularly “Sunburned GSP# 358” made me more aware, for a while, of how great an impact the sun—and light—have on our lives on a daily basis, and how important light is in art. The sun, as the subject of the three photos, seemed to be screaming from the frames something to the effect of, “Here I come!” and reminded me of the myth of Phaeton stealing Helios’s chariot, driving the sun across the sky and eventually losing control. The burnt edges of the solar path on the photo paper reminded me that the world is wild, and we only think we’re in charge.
The visible effect of the physics of taking a photograph also made me wonder about how to push my own drawings out past the edges, and although I doubt I’ll be burning holes in barrier paper this term, it is enticing to imagine the possibilities.